Welfare State

Cachet Fades: Hybrid Owners Trading for SUVs

by Bob Adelmann

hybrid_carTuesday’s announcement from Edmunds.com, the car-shopping website, that twice as many EV (electric and hybrid) owners are trading in their cars for gas-guzzling SUVs as they were just two years ago shouldn’t have caught anyone by surprise. The math never really made sense, and with gas prices half what they were two years ago, reality is neutering the “cachet” of owning an “environmentally friendly” automobile.

When gas was $4.67 a gallon in October 2012 it would take five years of gasoline savings to make up the difference between a Toyota Camry LE Hybrid ($28,230) and a Toyota Camry LE ($24,460). But with gas prices half that, it now takes more than 10 years to break even.

Not only is market reality disrupting and removing the “cachet,” it is also exposing the folly of government tinkering with subsidies and propaganda to make EVs competitive with internal combustion vehicles. In his 2011 State of the Union address, President Obama expressed his faith in government as the solution to all problems by predicting that “with more [federally subsidized] research and incentives [tax credits], we can break our dependence on oil … and become the first country to have a million electric vehicles on the road by 2015.”

His prediction, based on numbers from the Department of Energy (DOE), forecast the General Motors Chevrolet Volt would sell 375,000 vehicles by the end of 2014, and the Nissan Leaf EV 300,000 vehicles. Real world numbers illustrate clearly the size of that dreamland fantasy, conjured by believers in government subsidies. Through December 2014, total Volt sales came to just 71,867, while the Leaf’s total came in under 70,000.

Comparing the DOE’s dream to hard reality, the million-vehicle goal was missed by 826,000.

When it was clear in January 2013 that Obama’s goal wouldn’t be met, there was no heart change in Washington, just a moving of the goal posts. Putting the best face that he could on reality, Energy Secretary Steven Chu said: “Whether we meet that goal in 2015 or 2016, that’s less important than that we’re on the right path to get many millions of these vehicles on the road” — no matter the amount of taxpayers’ monies wasted in the process.

So far more than $8 billion of taxpayer dollars have been invested in failed ventures, federal tax credits, and experiments in making EVs more competitive with internal combustion vehicles, with little to show for it. One company, Fisker, was supposed to sell 230,000 EVs by the end of 2014. It never came close. Before suspending production in November 2012, it produced just 2,450 vehicles. It declared bankruptcy a year later, taking with it an estimated $200 million of those taxpayer funds.
Continue reading @ The New American

Related Posts:

Leave a Reply